Upon cross-examination witness slated that he did not think Dr. Bogle was much excited. He, however, permitted Mr. Moore to testify that there had been an agreement regarding the bill between himself and Mr. Miller and Dr. Bogle. Miller, who everyone agreed cussed like a preacher’s son, called Dr. Bogle a “thieving —- — — ——” the PD reported in its trial coverage, the paper thoughtfully using lines of varying width so you could try to puzzle out the censored words. Click here to look up your address! The jury took with them into the jury room five forms of verdict as follows: We, the jury, find the defendant, S. S. Bogle, guilty of murder in the first degree. Running around the house the other way she made her way to the front gate. THE TRIAL ENDED Witness then drew back, and told Miller he was a fool and had better go home. His Honor questioned them as to whether they wished any further instructions regarding the law. The Jury Deliberated Three Hours and a Quarter He testified that he had never heard of any one having taken a shot at Dr. Bogle. He also described circumstances subsequent to the discovery of the body. Counsel proceeded to point out that the defense would show that trouble over a bill was what led up to the unfortunate affair and he detailed some of the circumstances in connection therewith. And yes, the jury found him not guilty – but only after deliberating over three hours and taking nine votes. A short time afterwards and before the matter had been adjusted, the painter lost his position. The SELF-SUSTAINING community mentioned in the Press Democrat that we should investigate! Congratulations to our parents, students, and teachers! 1.”. all fully accredited and established leaders in providing online learning opportunities throughout the world. The Result of a Disagreement Over Money Matters The argument will then begin, and the case will go to the jury some time Monday or Monday night. Miller followed him in and began stalking back and forth at the front of the stable, looking angry and nervous. Miller made the remark “You are a — thief.” To this Dr. Bogle replied that he was not a thief. Then the district attorney closed the argument. Having no desire to meet Miller[,] witness then made his way through Orr & Stump’s saloon, which is located in the Dougherty-Shea block, into the lot in the rear and by the back stairs entered the building and made his way to his office. angle for this story is that he was also a well trained surgeon, and was probably the only physician in Santa Rosa who might have been able to save James M. Miller’s life. So, what now? At this stage of the proceedings Judge Carroll Cook, stated that as six people from Monterey had given character testimony that he thought that more witnesses from that section were unnecessary, as the district attorney was not going io introduce rebuttal testimony on the question of Dr. Bogle’s character. He examined the wound made by the bullet entering the hip, but not the other one. “I’m done for, I’m done for,” Miller said. He told the jury that they proposed to lift the curtain over Dr. Bogle’s life and would show his record and that they expected to show by the best men in Monterey and Sonoma counties and other places that his character for peace and quietude had been irreproachable. We, the jury, find the defendant, S. S. Bogle, guilty of murder in the second degree. They were taken back to the room and at midnight they announced that they had agreed upon the verdict stated above. Mrs. W. R. Farion of Indianapolis, a sister of Mrs. J. M. Miller, was sworn. The shooter was Dr. Samuel S. Bogle, a 32 year-old physician who had been in Santa Rosa less than two years. Mr. Miller had taken “an extraordinary large” drink of whiskey over his bar. The top attractions to visit in Santa Rosa are: What are the best outdoor activities in Santa Rosa? Healthy food choices in times of COVID-19 Jul 19, 2020. read more. The nut of his defense was that he believed Miller palmed a gun in his completely unseen right hand, then hid that hand behind his back while deftly pivoting toward Bogle to completely conceal what he was holding. Bogle’s two year-old daughter ran down the sidewalk to greet him; taking her hand, they were walking up their steps when Miller came out of his house, screaming “I’ll fix you yet, you G—d d—-n —- — — —-.